Allah and Yahweh disproved...?

Saying Allah knows he’ll make the grass blue in possible world

A and makes it orange is a logical contradiction, theists agree.

But saying Allah knows he’ll make the grass blue and couldn’t have made it orange and could have made it orange is a logical contradiction. 

Theists will say, “no, he knows he’s going to make the grass blue but could have made it orange because he knowingly chooses”. 

But as we agree that if he makes the grass orange that is a logical contradiction so he could not have made it orange.

Knowingly chooses is like saying married bachelor because you can’t know for certain you’ll do some and choose not to do it because, as we agree, that would lead to a logical contradiction: You can’t know for certain you’ll make the grass blue and have chosen to make it orange that is impossible.

Saying something is all-knowing and has freewill is logically contradictory not a paradox. Allah has to do what he knows and desires he’ll do. Something all-knowing can’t have freewill, can’t choose.

 

If true this would be a disproof of the gods Allah and Yahweh.




Saying Allah/Yahweh knows for certain he will create Adam and can't not create Adam but can not create Adam is a logical contradiction. Knowingly choosing is a contradiction because you can't know you'll do something and not do it because that leads to a contradiction: Saying...

Allah/Yahweh will create Adam and doesn't create Adam is a logical contradiction. So he knows he'll create Adam so must create Adam: He couldn't of not created Adam even if he wanted: Being all-knowing and having freewill are logically contradictory.

Allah/Yahweh disproved...?

 

Theists will say Allah can know he will create Adam and could have not created Adam - but he couldn't because that would lead to a logical contradiction. To know you will create Adam and not create Adam = A and ~A.





Allah and Yahweh disproof?


Saying God knows what he would freely choose is like saying he knows and chooses and doesn't choose (he has a choice and doesn't have a choice). A and ~A. It's a logical contradiction. God can't knowingly choose something, God doesn't choose at all, because he already knows the outcome.


God knows he would make the grass blue and makes it orange is a logical contradiction. But saying God knows he'll make the grass blue and can't make it orange but could make it orange is also a logical contradiction. God has no choice and must make the grass blue because he knows he'll do that very thing.


Something like a God, something omniscient, cannot be all knowing and have freewill as these are contradictory properties. All-knowing/omniscient freewill is a logical contradiction. 


This would be a disproof of both Allah and Yahweh if true as they are Gods who know the outcome of everything - they can tell the future for all eternity. 


 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Why Allah and Yahweh certainly do not exist.